Former Grizzlies in NCAA Basketball
| Player | Years at Butler | School |
| Kaleb Washington | 2023-24 | Florida A&M |
| Dorien Johnson | 2023-24 | Wilmington University |
| Amare Haynie | 2023-24 | Elizabeth City State University |
| Jason 'Deuce' Drake | 2023-24 | Drexel |
| Jamichael Stillwell | 2023-24 | UW-Milwaukee |
| Christian Richardson | 2022-24 | Long Beach State |
| Tahjae Hill | 2022-23 | Wayland Baptist University |
| Noah Simmons | 2022-23 | Benedictine College |
| Eli Wiseman | 2021-23 | Bethel College |
| Caleb Golden | 2021-23 | Oklahoma Christian University |
| Javon Grant | 2022-23 | Oklahoma Christian University |
| Isaiah Williams | 2022-23 | Academy of Art University (CA) |
| Treylon Payne | 2020-23 | Academy of Art University (CA) |
| Rob Brown | 2022-23 | Nicholls State |
| Isaac Ondekane | 2022-23 | Lindenwood University/Omaha |
| Jaden Okon | 2020-21 | Cameron University |
| Keyon Thomas | 2019-21 | East Central University |
| Eden Holt | 2020-21 | UW-Milwaukee |
| Karrington Davis | 2020-21 | Lindenwood University |
| Shawn Hopkins | 2019-21 | Minnesota State |
| DeeJuan Pruitt | 2020-21 | SIU Edwardsville/Jacksonville University |
| Noah Thomasson | 2020-21 | Georgia |
| Juwan White | 2018-20 | Stony Brook |
| Marque English | 2019-20 | University of Northern Colorado |
| Ndongo Ndaw | 2019-20 | Indiana State University |
| Javaunte Hawkins | 2019-20 | Florida International University |
| Tracy Jones | 2019-20 | Newman University |
| Grehlon Easter | 2019-20 | CSU Bakersfield |
| Jonil Fugett | 2018-19 | West Texas A&M University |
| Sam Ward | 2018-19 | University of Illinois Chicago |
| Immanuel Allen | 2018-19 | Abilene Christina University |
| Jared Armstrong | 2017-18 | Slippery Rock University |
| Anthony Bratton | 2017-18 | University of Texas Rio Grande Valley |
| RJ Allen | 2017-18 | Sam Houston State University |
| Will Adler | 2015-17 | Angelo State |
| Jacoby Harris | 2015-17 | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Johnny Lindsey | 2016-17 | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Chris Howell | 2014-16 | South Dakota State |
| Caelan Neal | 2014-16 | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Derrick Byrd | 2014-16 | Texas A&M - Kingsville |
| Travis House | 2014-16 | Rockhurst |
| Damien Akao | 2014-16 | Newman |
| Kyle Steward | 2014-15 | Missouri-Kansas City |
| Lamar Wofford | 2013-15 | Eastern Michigan |
| Larry Fitzgerald | 2012-2014 | Northwest Missouri State |
| Shomari Triggs | 2012-2014 | Coppin State |
| Sean Goodwin | 2012-2014 | Sam Houston State University |
| Ja'ln Williams | 2011-2013 | Lindsey Wilson College |
| Eric Watson | 2011-2013 | Baker |
| Sean Osler | 2011-2013 | Drury |
| Zac Bargen | 2010-2012 | Chadron State |
| Justin Simmons | 2011-2012 | Nebraska-Omaha |
| Andre Ingram | 2009-2011 | Minnesota |
| Joshua Gibbs | 2009-2011 | Sam Houston State University |
| Caleb Walker | 2008-2010 | Nebraska |
| Anthony Cousin | 2009-2010 | Illinois State |
| Troy Pierce | 2008-2010 | Charleston Southern, Emporia State |
| Mark Morgan | 2008-2010 | Ottawa |
| Luke Engelken | 2008-2009 | Gardner-Webb |
| Maurice Colter | 2008-2009 | Washburn |
| Corey Bailey | 2004-2006 | UNLV |
| Chadd Dunn | 2004-2006 | Regis |
| Ajay Calvin | 2003-2005 | Drake |
| Kevin Menifee | 2003-2005 | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi |
| Chris Lee | 2002-2004 | Southeastern Louisiana |
| Ed Spencer | 2001-2003 | UNC Wilmington |
| Chris Exilus | 2001-2002 | DePaul |
| James Peters | 2000-2002 | UNLV |
| Derek Cline | 2000-2001 | Northeastern State |
| Tony Allen | 2000-2001 | Oklahoma State |
| Kasib Powell | 1999-2001 | Texas Tech |
| Jaborri Thomas | 1999-2000 | Chaminade |
| Brandon Morris | 1998-2000 | Drury |
| Geoff Riley | 1998-2000 | Fort Hays State |
| Steve Rothwell | 1998-2000 | Colorado School of the Mines |
| Jarvis Mitchell | 1998-1999 | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Todd Kappelman | 1997-1999 | Kansas |
| Tony Jackson | 1997-1999 | Mississippi State |
| Michael Jackson | 1997-1999 | UMKC |
| Matt Suther | 1997-1999 | UMKC |
| William Gates | 1997-1999 | Idaho |
| Jamar Gaither | 1997-1998 | West Virginia |
| Tyrone Brown | 1996-1998 | Illinois State |
| Lucas Sims | 1996-1998 | Emporia State |
| Lee Nailon | 1996-1997 | TCU |
| Yasir Rosemond | 1996-1997 | Oregon |
| Jermaine McCleod | 1995-1997 | Wichita State |
| Cedric McGinnis | 1995-1997 | Georgia Southern |
| Mao Tosi | 1995-1997 | Idaho State |
| Matt Watts | 1995-1997 | San Diego State |
| Delvin Washington | 1995-1997 | Iowa State |
| Geoff Markos | 1995-1996 | UMKC |
| Terry Hankton | 1994-1996 | Wichita State |
| Ty Rhodes | 1994-1996 | Wichita State |
| Scott McMillin | 1994-1996 | Buffalo |
| Tyrone Caswell | 1994-1995 | Saint Louis |
| Andre McLeod | 1994-1995 | Nevada-Reno |
| Brian Alexander | 1994-1995 | Detroit Mercy |
| Chris Grill | 1993-1995 | Marist / Wichita State |
| Martin Lewis | 1993-1994 | Oklahoma State |
| Geoff Eck | 1993-1994 | Fort Hays State |
| Mark Eck | 1993-1994 | Lamar University |
| John Jackson | 1992-1994 | Mississippi |
| Brian Jackson | 1992-1994 | Evansville |
| Quincy Alexander | 1992-1994 | UNC-Charlotte |
| Roy Wells | 1992-1994 | UNC-Charlotte |
| Wilson Winters | 1991-1993 | Georgia Southern |
| Ervin Garnes | 1991-1993 | Mississippi |
| Eric Thomas | 1991-1993 | Loyola |
| Scot McCabe | 1991-1993 | Marist |
| Cleveland Jackson | 1990-1992 | Georgia |
| Rod Pryor | 1990-1992 | Middle Tennessee State |
| Miles Powers | 1990-1992 | Duquesne |
| Rodney McCoy | 1990-1992 | Texas-El Paso |
| Kent Bennet | 1990-1991 | San Francisco |
| Brent Atwater | 1990-1991 | TCU |
| Tony Johnson | 1990-1991 | Wichita State |
| Val Barnes | 1990-1991 | Iowa |
| Gaylon Nickerson | 1990-1991 | Kansas State |
| Melvin Johnson | 1989-1991 | McNeese State |
| Mike Schreiber | 1989-1991 | Marist |
| Darrel Harmon | 1989-1991 | Texas-Arlington |
| Billy Law | 1988-1990 | Colorado |
| Herbert Jones | 1988-1990 | Cincinnati |
| Chad Wold | 1988-1990 | Kansas State |
| Darrin Harvey | 1988-1990 | Fort Hays State |
| Jason Thompson | 1987-1989 | Washington State |
| Willie Newson | 1987-1989 | UTSA |
| Chuck Armstead | 1987-1989 | Georgia State |
| Van Gray | 1987-1989 | Utah |
| Carlos Diggins | 1985-1987 | Kansas State |
| Watkins Singletary | 1985-1987 | Utah |
| Floyd Johnson | 1985-1987 | Akron |
| Juric Brown | 1985-1986 | Arkansas-Little Rock |