| 2020-2021 | |
| Tamara Nard - University of Houston - NCAA D1 | |
| Paris Mullins - Auburn University - NCAA D1 | |
| Skyla Knight - Ball State - NCAA D 1 | |
| Carissa Beck - Newman University - NCAA D2 | |
| Riley Hett - Quincy University - NCAA D2 | |
| 2019-2020 | |
| RaVon Nero - University of Missouri Kansas City - NCAA D1 | |
| Camille Downs - University of North Carolina Willmington - NCAA D1 | |
| Dana Johnson - Pittsburg State University - NCAA D2 | |
| Jaelynn McLaurian - Texas A&M International - NCAA D2 | |
| Zayda Perez - Bethel College - NAIA | |
| Jelesa Gross - Southwestern Christian University - NAIA | |
| 2018-2019 | |
| Lauryn Snipes - Indiana State - NCAA D1 | |
| Jalise Smallwood - Southern Mississippi - NCAA D1 | |
| Kyla Callins - University of Missouri Kansas City - NCAA D1 | |
| Kayna Simoneau - Sacramento State - NCAA D1 | |
| Taylor Birch - Southwest Baptist (MO) - NCAA D2 | |
| Deztinee Gooden - Bethany College - NAIA | |
| 2017-2018 | |
| Ericka Mattingly - University of Missouri Kansas City - NCAA D1 | |
| Raegan Sanchez - Minot State - NCAA D2 | |
| Jaiden Easter - Friends University - NAIA | |
| HaLee Roland - Friends University - NAIA | |
| 2016-2017 | |
| Dakota Vann - Texas Christian University - NCAA D1 | |
| Raven Prince - Wichita State University - NCAA D1 | |
| Alecia Gulledge - Austin Peay - NCAA D1 | |
| Nakylia Carter - Wagoner | |
| Kyeria Hannah - Angelo State | |
| Imari Bell - Oklahoma Baptist | |
| 2015-16 | |
| Janee Arnold - Missouri-Kansas City | |
| Nia Roberts – Newman University | |
| Eledria Franklin - St. Louis School of Pharmacy | |
| Tamara Lee - Wichita State | |
| 2014-15 | |
| Amari Dennis | Texas Southern University (NCAA DI) |
| Ashley Gibson | Southern Methodist University (NCAA DI) |
| Kynadi Johnson | University of Minnesota (NCAA DI) |
| Katie Palmer | University of Washington (NCAA DI) |
| Sarah Paker | Oklahoma Christian University (NCAA DII) |
| Jurnee Reid | Tabor College (NAIA DII) |
| 2013-14 | |
| Ashlee Ivy | Wichita State University (NCAA DI) |
| Te'era Williams | University of Tulsa (NCAA DI) |
| Teanna Reid | University of Tulsa (NCAA DI) |
| Terryuana Godwin | University of Georgia (NCAA DI) |
| Shayla Williams | Eastern New Mexico (NCAA DII) |
| Katie Andersen | Rockhurst University (NCAA DII) |
| Bethany Howard | Huntingdon College (NCAA DIII) |
| Chelsea Hodison | Ottawa University (NAIA DII) |
| 2012-13 | |
| Jamillah Bonner | Wichita State University |
| Tysia Manuel | Oral Roberts University |
| Carly Bettencourt | Quincy University |
| Samantha Satterlee | Lincoln Memorial University |
| 2011-12 | |
| April Miller | Benedictine |
| Tonya Elliott-Salas | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Kiara O'Neal | Claflin Univeristy |
| 2010-2011 | |
| Abby Fawcett | Friends University |
| Tierra Andrews | Friends University |
| LT Sims | Friends University |
| Paige Franklin | West Texas A&M University |
| 2009-2010 | |
| Abby Henning | Newman University |
| 2008-2009 | |
| Damara Lewis | Kansas Wesleyan University |
| Angie Criner | University of Georgia |
| Jacque Dean | Friends University |
| Raneisha Hunter | Nicholls State University |
| Brittany Aldrich | University of Alaska-Fairbanks |
| Demika Holt | Anderson University |
| 2007-2008 | |
| Lakeshia Levi | Kent State University |
| Kelsey Bruner | Friends University |
| 2006-07 | |
| Megan Cherry | University of Nevada |
| Danae Stuckey | Iowa State University |
| Kelsey Van Sickle | Oklahoma State University |
| 2005-06 | |
| Elizabeth Witte | University of Idaho |
| 2003-04 | |
| Cecilia Russell-Nava | New Mexico State University |
| Previous Years | |
| Ashley Roberts | Texas-Pan American |
| Jamie Bernsten | Friends |
| Bethany Kanak | Bethany |
| Ena Daniels | Western Illinois |
| Jackie Moore | Oklahoma State |
| LaDonna Edmondson | Central State (Ohio) |
| Tamika Lomax | Lander |
| Stephanie Brown | Southern Illinois |
| Emily Martin | Missouri Southern |
| Betty Lennox | Louisiana Tech |
| Jerrica Miller | UNC-Asheville |
| Katie Guy | Saint Mary College |
| Shalisha Davis | West Virginia Tech |
| Lisa Hoelting | Washburn |
| Nicole Heinz | Missouri Southern |
| LaRissa Sargeant | Central Missouri State |
| Joni Brown | Ottawa |
| Tonya Foster | Missouri Western |
| Danika Kelley | Michigan State |
| Rebecca Horst | Hawaii |
| Staci Doffing | West Texas State |
| Leigh Young | Carson-Newman |
| Lisa Toburen | Fort Hays State |
| Kris Earhart | Missouri-St. Louis |
| Shannon Armstrong | Friends |
| Joyce Borg | Tabor |
| Nancy Taliafero | Clemson |
| Dianne Kelley | Nebraska-Kearney |
| Kristi Ramsey | Bethany |
| Tiffany Poling | Kansas |
| Carrie Duquette | Wichita State |
| Kristy Tabor | Missouri-Kansas City |
| Kesha Walker | Texas-San Antonio |
| Maria Camacho | Nevada |
| Jessica Meyers | Friends |
| Meila Leigh | Xavier |
| Amy Goodwin | Southwest Baptist |
| Deedra Pyle | Tabor |
| Tamekia Drayer | Northern Illinois |
| Shannon Griffith | Morningside |
| Delores Johnson | Sam Houston State |
| Tracy Eaton | Arkansas |
| Gloria Clark | Missouri-St. Louis |
| Emily Unruh | Washburn |
| Vicki Bauer | Ottawa |
| Tina Tunink | LaSalle |
| Renee Bellerive | Friends |
| Lisa Tyson | Ottawa |
| Patti Newton | Colorado |
| Heather Cogswell | Idaho State |
| Cindy Bolen | Emporia State |
| Jean Linot | Emporia State |
Women's Basketball
Butler Grizzlies are supported by LASIK Omaha eye doctors and eye surgeons.
